How Well Do You Know Your Candidates? Blog Feature
Dan Fisher

By: Dan Fisher on September 6th, 2011

Print/Save as PDF

How Well Do You Know Your Candidates?

IT Recruitment

Every month I speak with dozens of sales & recruiting professionals, business owners, CEO’s and industry Preparing candidates for client interviewexecutives. And over the past several months I have been hearing the same thing. “We lost another candidate at the 11th hour, the candidate took another opportunity.”

When I probe to better understand the situation and why this is happening it becomes pretty clear. Candidates are taking other job opportunities-usually opportunities their sales and recruiting team we’re unaware of or, lacked the ability to sell against.

This bears the question, how well do you know your candidates?

What I have come to discover is most sales and recruiting professionals understand the service that they sell and offer but far fewer truly understand the product (consultant) they’re selling.

How do I define the difference? The service is simply the tasks you complete internally-source, screen, interview, test, and reference check your consultants-in order to deliver your product. Your product of course is your consultant/candidate. Understanding your service-and performing those tasks are important. But this market has proven that understanding your product is far more critical to winning business. Let me explain.

When I ask probing questions to understand what went wrong and why the recruiter lost the candidate “at the 11th hour,” they share with me one of the following:

  • “We knew there was another opportunity (but didn’t know any of the details of that opportunity or never asked the necessary drill-down questions on the opportunity).”
  • “We didn’t know there was another opportunity.”
  • “The candidate said this was his/her top choice/opportunity.”
When I probe further for additional information to better understand what is happening the answers get even more vague. My point is, recruiters and sales professionals alike too often know very little about their candidates current situation and their candidate's decision making processThis is costing them, BIG TIME!
They often don’t understand who their candidate is, why they’re even interested in a new project or making a career move or why they would take their opportunity. Far too often recruiters fail to quality what motivates the candidate and how they make decisions. 

Since about Q2 of this year I have noticed this trend taking hold among many IT staffing organizations and IT recruiters. What’s happening is we’re simply sourcing vs. recruiting.

Many recruiters are only spending 10-15 minutes total on the phone with their candidates. There can be many reasons for this but I suspect the primary reason ties in with the industry mantra of “more is always better.” Recruiters often want to get as many submittals out as they possibly can to increase their likelihood of closing business. But how well can you get to know someone and screen them in a 10-15 minute conversation? This behavior is analogous to the behavior associated with a VMS or MSP program. My experience is that many VMS or MSP programs place a greater value on the volume of resumes being submitted by the vendor than actually placing candidates.

With the IT market booming, my observation is that many recruiters (and managers often drive this behavior) are placing a greater value on the number of their submittals vs. the quality of their submittals and making placements. Anyone can source candidates but can you deliver talent? 

Many recruiters are losing candidates in the first five minutes (or even less) of a conversation. The heart and soul of recruiting is building trust.  And critical to building trust is the ability of disarming candidates and making them feel comfortable with you to earn their trust. This is a skill that has to be taught and then practiced over and over and over again. Even some experienced recruiters struggle with developing this skill. So, if we only spend 10-15 minutes on the phone and 95% of that time is focused exclusively on qualifying candidates and matching them with your opportunity and not building trust and exhibiting behaviors that build trust, then why should we expect the candidate (a total stranger) to be completely open and honest with us when it comes time to extend an offer and work out a contract? 

The second reason is inexperience or lack of training. My observation is that many recruiters are often afraid to ask the “tough” questions. They’re afraid if they ask the questions they know they should be asking that they might put the candidate off and thus lose the candidate and the submittal. And when that happens their numbers (submittals) go down, and that makes a recruiter look bad to management and their peers. This of course makes no sense at all. Or, they may ask the questions but they don’t know how to ask the question in a way that will solicit an honest response from the candidate. Again, it’s the job of the recruiter to build trust and create a “safe environment” where your candidate is comfortable with 100% transparency. There is skill involved in creating this environment between you and your candidate.

Looking for additional insight into interviewing candidates? Download the eBook titled "Executing the Candidate Interview, Five Pillars to Effective Qualification."

Executing Candidate Interviews for Effective Qualification


About Dan Fisher

I’m Dan Fisher, founder of Menemsha Group. Over 400 IT staffing firms including thousands of sales reps and recruiters apply my sales methodology including my scripts, playbooks, job aids, tools and templates, all of which is consumed from our SaaS based sales enablement platform and our mobile application. I’ve coached and mentored hundreds of sales leaders, business owners and CEO’s, and I have spoken at a variety of industry events including Staffing World, Bullhorn Engage, TechServe Alliance, Bullhorn Live, Massachusetts Staffing Association, and National Association of Personnel Services. Since 2008 I've helped IT staffing organizations quickly ramp up new hires, slash the time it takes to get new reps to open new accounts and meet quota, get more high-quality meetings with key decision makers and help leaders build a scalable sales organization. My training and coaching programs are engaging and highly interactive and are known to challenge sellers to rethink how they approach selling. Ultimately, I help sellers increase productivity, accelerate the buying process & win more deals.

  • Connect with Dan Fisher